18 Feb 2008 04:38:05 | Dr. Jeffrey A. Oster, Medical Director Of
Morton's Neuroma is a common foot condition caused by the
irritation of the common intermetatarsal nerve as it passes
through the forefoot to the toes. This condition was first
described by Dr. Morton, a Viennese physician, in 1876.
To help understand this condition, let's break the word down
into its' root terms. Neuro, of course, relates to the nervous
system. Oma is the Latin term that defines a tumor or swelling
that is of primary origin. Put the terms together and what is
described is a tumor or swelling of a peripheral nerve. For most
of us, the term tumor sends up a red flag and really gets our
attention. Not all tumors are the bad or so called malignant
types we tend to hear so much about. The term tumor simply
defines a swelling that develops with no other recognizable
cause.
One of the tests your doctor may use to diagnose Morton's
Neuroma is called a Muldier's Sign (1). To perform this test,
your doctor will gently squeeze the foot from side to side and
use their thumb to push up between the 3rd and 4th toes. In
advanced cases of Morton's Neuroma, there will be a palpable
snap as the intermetatarsal nerve moves between the adjacent
bones. Performing a Muldier's Sign mimics what takes place in
the shoe with every step. Squeezing the foot simulates the shoe
and pushing up on the bottom of the foot simulates the reactive
forces of the ground as it pushes against the foot with each
step.
Tight shoes will contribute to the symptoms of Morton's Neuroma
by binding the forefoot and compressing the nerve. Higher heels
will also act to increase the ground reactive forces. Certain
activities, such as squatting, will also increase the force
applied to the plantar foot and aggregate the symptoms of
Morton's Neuroma.
We've learned a lot about Morton's neuroma over the past ten
years. A podiatrist in the Houston Texas area, Dr. Steve
Barrett, was the one individual who really changed the way that
we treat Morton's Neuroma. It's interesting to note that we've
treated Morton's Neuroma the same for the past 100 years ever
since it was first described by Dr. Morton. Dr. Barrett was the
first to take a critical look at Morton's Neuroma and recognize
how this problem develops and perhaps, how could we treat it
more effectively.
What Dr. Barrett recognized was that the common intermetatarsal
nerve, the peripheral nerve where we find Morton's Neuroma,
became entrapped as it passed beneath the intermetatarsal
ligament. This was a new concept for us in light of the fact
that we had considered Morton's Neuroma something that was the
effect of the adjacent bone irritating the nerve. In fact, Dr.
Barrett's findings made Morton's Neuroma similar to other nerve
entrapments such as carpal tunnel. Subsequently, the treatment
of Morton's Neuroma has been slowly changing over the last ten
years as the result of a new endoscopic surgical procedure first
described by Dr. Barrett.
Not all Morton's Neuroma require surgical correction. 50% or
more of new Morton's Neuroma patients respond to simple changes
in shoes such as a wider toe box. Shoe padding can also help
treat Morton's Neuroma. Metatarsal pads are an important tool
for patients with Morton's neuroma symptoms. A metatarsal pad is
a small lift that is positioned in the shoe just proximal
(behind) the weight bearing surface of the metatarsal bones. A
metatarsal pad lifts and separates the metatarsal bones thereby
decreasing the wear on the intermetatarsal nerve. Metatarsal
pads come in varying sizes and densities, therefore it's
important to have your pedorthist or shoe repair shop position
and glue the pad. Higher quality prefabricated arch supports
come with a metatarsal pad already seated in the correct
position. Using inserts with a metatarsal pad is sometimes the
easier way to go because they can be moved from shoe to shoe.
If padding and shoe changes don't work, we fall back on some of
the original suggestions of Dr. Morton, first and foremost,
injections of cortisone. Bear in mind, we've discussed the fact
that Morton's Neuroma is a nerve entrapment. Cortisone does not
change the fact that the common intermetatarsal nerve is prone
to become entrapped, but it can reduce the painful inflammation
in the nerve. If we can use cortisone effectively and avoid
surgery, all the better. It's interesting that cortisone, unlike
other medications, comes with no directions for treating
Morton's Neuroma. Much of the use of cortisone depends upon the
previous experiences of your doctor and the successes or
failures that he or she has seen with cortisone. Can you overuse
cortisone? Yes you can. But it's actually the safest and most
effective medication for Morton's Neuroma and therefore should
be used when needed. Over use of injectable cortisone in
treating Morton's Neuroma can contribute to atrophy or thinning
of the fat pad of the bottom of the foot.
That brings up another interesting point. Dr. Morton's original
treatment plan as described in 1895 included changes in shoes,
multiple injections of cortisone and if necessary, complete
excision of the common intermetatarsal nerve. We've mentioned
before that Morton's Neuroma is a nerve entrapment much like
carpal tunnel. Now let's see if we can apply Dr. Morton's
treatment plan to a carpal tunnel case. Perhaps we'd splint the
wrist, try some injectable cortisone, but completely excise the
nerve? No way. But that's what's been done for the past 100
years for Morton's Neuroma. Post-op complications were common
and included thinning of the plantar fat pad and loss of
sensation in the 3rd and 4th toes.
The introduction of Dr. Barrett's EDIN procedure has
revolutionized the treatment of Morton's Neuroma and really
represents the first unique contribution to treating this
condition in over 100 years. The EDIN procedure stands for
endoscopic decompression of the common intermetatarsal nerve.
Interestingly enough, Steve describes first thinking about this
procedure as he watched another surgeon perform an endoscopic
carpal tunnel surgery. Steve recognized the problem to be the
ligament and not the nerve. The EDIN procedure selectively
releases the ligament and leaves the nerve intact.
The EDIN procedure provides us with a new alternative. In the
past we knew that the traditional surgery used to treat Morton's
Neuroma, called a neurectomy, was destructive and carried a fair
amount of post-op complications. Therefore, we would tend to use
excessive amounts of cortisone as our only method of treatment.
The EDIN procedure provides a new alternative using non-invasive
endoscopic techniques that usually return patients to activities
much sooner than the traditional surgery. And, what I find most
helpful is the fact that it enables us to use less cortisone,
thereby avoiding fat pad atrophy. Was fat pad atrophy due to the
neurectomy or from the overuse of cortisone? The EDIN procedure
shows none of the traditional post-op complications as seen in
the neurectomy, therefore we can assume that fat pad atrophy was
in part due to overuse of cortisone. Thanks Steve; I like a guy
who can think outside of the box.
Surgeons are slow to change, and rightly so. They prefer to use
what they were taught and not test new procedures on their
patients. The EDIN procedure has been used for at least ten
years and has shown promising results. It can be technically
challenging for some who are not familiar with endoscopic
techniques. As with other surgical procedures there are pros,
cons and possible complication that need to be discussed
thoroughly with your physician prior to surgery.
There are other non-surgical methods of treating Morton's
neuroma. Sclerosis of the nerve with diluted alcohol (4%)
injections is starting to gain popularity (2). Multiple
injections are used to scar the wall of the nerve and inhibit
inflammation. Recent literature suggests injections weekly for
three to seven weeks. The success rates of injectable sclerosing
solutions have been reported to be as high as 60-90%.
Another new technique is called cryogenic neuroablation. Cryo
surgery is surgery that uses extremely cold instrumentation to
selectively destroy tissue. Cryosurgery has been used commonly
to destroy superficial skin lesions such as warts and moles. In
the case of Morton's neuroma, work has recently been done by
several Michigan podiatrists that suggests cryogenic
neuroablation may have a future in treating Morton's neuroma.
The technique uses what is referred to as the Joule-Thompson
effect. The Joule-Thompson effect occurs when a gas is passed
through an area where it may expand. As the gas expands, it
cools to approximately -70 degrees centigrade . In the case of
neuroablation, the expansion of the gas is controlled in a 5.5
mm probe that freezes and subsequently destroys the nerve tissue.
In the cryogenic ablation study carried out by Drs. Caporusso,
Fallet and Savoy-Moore, thirty one neuromas were treated in 20
patients. All procedures were performed in an office setting.
The proecdure used a small amount of local anesthetic to numb
the skin to allow the passage of a 12-gauge cannula through the
skin. A nerve stimulator was passed through the cannula to
locate the nerve. Once the position of the nerve was
established, two three minute freeze sessions were utilized to
destroy the nerve tissue. A sterile dressing was applied to the
site and the patient was dismissed without the need for pain
medication. The study cites a 65% success rate.
Anatomy:
As the posterior tibial nerve descends the leg, it biforcates
(splints into two parts) at the level of the medial ankle. The
two branches, the medial and lateral plantar nerves, continue
forward into the foot to supply motor function to the muscles of
the foot and sensory innervation to the bottom of the foot. The
medial and lateral plantar nerves converge at the 3rd interspace
(the space between the 3rd and 4th toes) to form the 3rd common
intermetatarsal nerve. As a result of this unique anatomical
configuration, the nerve between the 3rd and 4th toes is bound
and unable to move out of the way when the adjacent bones move
in the forefoot. As a result, the 3rd common intermetatarsal
nerve is much more prone to the formation of Morton's Neuroma.
As the 3rd common intermetatarsal nerve passes distally to the
toes it is forced to pass beneath the intermetatarsal ligament.
At this point the nerve takes a slight turn in direction as it
passes into the 3rd and 4th toes. This is the primary location
where a Morton's Neuroma is found.
Biomechanics:
Biomechanics do contribute to the formation of Morton's
Neuroma. Morton's Neuroma is more commonly seen in flat feet and
flexible feet. It is not uncommon to find Morton's Neuroma in
conjunction with other foot problems such as bunions and hammer
toes.
Symptoms:
A dull achy sensation in the forefoot, usually between the 3rd
and 4th toes Pain that increased with the time a person spent on
their feet, particularly in high heels Pain that decreased once
a person got off their feet Numbness of the 3rd and 4th toes A
sensation of walking on something, such as a bunched up sock
Occasionally, a snapping sensation or electrical shock sensation
Differential Diagnosis:
Bursitis/capsulitis
Metatarsalgia
Metatarsal stress fracture
Additional references include;
Dockery GL: The Treatment of Intermetatarsal Neuromas With 4%
Sclerosing Injections. JFAS, 38(6):403-408, 1999
Miller SJ: Morton's Neuroma: A Syndrome. In McGlamry ED, Banks
AS, Downey MS (ed): Comprehensive Textbook Of Foot Surgery, 2nd
ed. Ch.11, Williams and Wilkens, Baltimore, 1992;304-320
Mendicino, SS, Rockett MA:Morton's Neuroma: Update On Diagnosis
And Imaging. Clin Pod Med. Surg. 14:303-311, 1997
Caporusso, EF, Fallet, L, Savoy_Moore, R: Cryogenic
Neuroablation for the Treatment of Lower Extremity Neuromas.
JFAS, 41(5):286-290, 2002
About Author :
Jeffrey A. Oster, DPM, C.Ped is a board certified foot and ankle
surgeon. Dr. Oster is also board certified in pedorthics. Dr.
Oster is medical director of