09 Mar 2008 03:49:55 | George A. Parker
According to the Equipment Leasing Association (“ELA”), U.S.
businesses lease every thing from laptop computers to commercial
airplanes, racking up more than $ 200 billion in equipment
leased each year. Although four out of five U.S. companies use
leasing to acquire equipment, many don’t know the ins and outs
of leasing well enough to negotiate a good deal. By focusing on
a few key aspects of the lease transaction, you can save a
bundle on your next lease and eliminate potential aggravation.
1. Choose the Right Leasing Partner
The starting point for saving money on your lease is to select
the right leasing company. The biggest savings in this area come
from saving time and dodging substandard lease transactions. The
wrong lessor choice can result in a slow approval, inability of
the lessor to deliver, hidden fees, a poorly designed lease
transaction or worst. Give this aspect of obtaining a lease your
highest priority. To save a bundle on your next lease, you must
do your homework in pre-qualifying bidding leasing companies.
Look for lessors with: 1) experience and knowledge; 2) good
reputations; 3) the ability to perform; 4) helpful business
contacts; and 6) a relationship approach. Ask for and get lessor
financial information, background information on the key
managers, a listing of recently completed leases, and contacts
at key funding sources for each leasing company being
considered. Review this information and follow up with all
contacts provided.
2. Choose the Right Lease You can rake in big savings by
obtaining the right lease for the equipment you are acquiring.
When planning your lease financing, determine the top three or
four attributes your lease should have. During this process,
carefully evaluate the importance of: lease pricing, lease
flexibility, balance sheet considerations, equipment
obsolescence, the anticipated period of equipment usage, and
your firm’s credit status. The wrong lease choice can be costly.
Lease pricing is market driven, so get at least three lease
bids. Carefully evaluate bids by doing a comparative analysis of
discounted cash flows incorporating all anticipated costs and
fees. Make sure your lease has favorable end-of-lease options, a
reasonable end-of-lease notice period, the ability to relocate
equipment by notifying the lessor, the right to terminate the
lease early without an onerous charge, and the right to assign
the lease to another user under agreed upon conditions. Look for
an arrangement that will cover equipment needs for at least the
next six to twelve months.
Big savings can be realized by knowing when to select a lease
with a bargain purchase option versus a fair market value
option. If you know you will be keeping the equipment beyond the
initial lease term, a bargain purchase option is usually the
most cost-effective alternative. If the equipment is prone to
obsolescence or if it is unlikely you will retain the equipment
at the end of the lease, consider a lease with fair market
value, end-of-lease options.
Know your firm’s credit standing. If your firm has been in
business for a number of years, is profitable, has a good track
record and has a strong balance sheet, it deserves great lease
pricing and terms. If your firm has a spotty credit record or
weak balance sheet, the challenge is to get the best deal
possible. Identify and offer credit enhancements that will make
your transaction more attractive. Allow plenty of time to get
through the credit review and due diligence process.
3. Ask for Fair Market Value ‘Caps’
If you decide that a fair market value lease is the way to go,
you can realize big savings by limiting that value. Fair market
value rental and purchase options at the end of the lease allow
the lessee to either continue leasing the equipment or to buy
the equipment at the then fair market value. These values are
generally quoted by the lessor at lease end based on aftermarket
data, but most leases allow the lessee to obtain an appraisal
from a qualified equipment appraiser. To realize significant
savings and to eliminate unpleasant surprises, request fair
market value options that are “capped” (have upper limits).
Beware, however. Lessors may insist on fair market value
‘floors’ (lower limits) when they agree to ‘caps’. The
availability of a fair market value cap will depend on the size
of the transaction (may not be available on small transactions),
competition among lessors, and the credit status of your firm.
4. Keep the End-of-lease Notice and Renewal Periods Short
To avoid hefty unintended lease charges, seek notice and
automatic renewal periods that are short. The primary purpose of
the end-of-lease notice period is to allow the leasing company
sufficient time to redeploy the equipment if you elect to return
the equipment. The secondary purpose is to notify the lessor of
your plan to either continue leasing the equipment or to
purchase it. The notice period generally ranges from one to six
months, with three months being typical. If you violate the
notice period, the lease kicks into an often unfavorable
automatic renewal period, usually one to six months. If the
lessor is unwilling to negotiate this provision, you can save
money by making sure the notice requirement is fulfilled within
the allowed time.
5. Slash Interim Rent
You can slash lease costs significantly by limiting interim
rent. Interim rent is the rent you pay for daily use of
equipment between the equipment acceptance and lease start
dates. The rationale for interim rent is that you have use of
the equipment and the lessor is obligated to pay the equipment
vendor during this period. While the rationale is not
unreasonable, interim rent can balloon lease pricing by
arbitrarily extending the term of the lease (albeit by only
days). The best approach is to schedule equipment delivery and
acceptance toward the end of the month. Most lease terms
officially start the first day of the month following equipment
acceptance. Another strategy is to negotiate a truncated period
at the end of the lease such that the interim period and
truncated period total one month of the quoted lease term. A
last strategy is to request a limit on interim rent (perhaps ten
or fifteen days) regardless of equipment acceptance.
6. Manage Equipment Returns
Save a bundle on your lease by managing the equipment’s return.
Although you may not anticipate returning the equipment to the
leasing company at lease end, it can be costly if you do. When
equipment is returned, most lessors care about and will hold
your firm accountable for the equipment’s condition. Equipment
should be properly maintained and returned in good condition.
Make sure that you understand the return provision of the lease
and that you have good internal controls to adhere to these
requirements. If the lease contains an ‘all or none’ return
provision, one strategy is to subdivide the lease into several
smaller lease schedules on the front end. Place equipment you
are most likely to keep on the same schedules. Try to negotiate
the right to return up to 20% of the equipment (based on
original value) at the end of the lease, as long as you agree to
renew the lease or purchase the balance of the equipment. Track
and save all equipment accessories and documentation.
7. Match Lease Term with Projected Equipment Use
The term of the lease should match the expected use of the
equipment as closely as possible to save money. If the term is
too short, cash outlays for the equipment might exceed the
expected equipment benefits over the term. If the lease term is
too long, you might lose the flexibility of upgrading to newer
more desirable equipment. Notwithstanding your preferences, the
term allowed by the leasing company may depend on their
perception of credit risk and the expected economic life of the
equipment. Any mismatch between your preference and lessor’s can
be managed by obtaining favorable end-of-lease options.
8. Identify and Understand All Potential Fees
Leasing proposals vary in the types and amounts of fees and
penalty charges. Common fees and charges include: commitment
fees; non-use fees or facility fees; per schedule documentation
charges; attorney fees; UCC financing statements; penalty
charges for late rental payments; and early lease termination
charges. These are only a few of the possible fees and charges.
You can save a bundle by carefully going through each lease
proposal and lease agreement to identify and compare likely
charges. If fees or charges are significant and likely, they
should be incorporated into your pricing analysis. Where
possible, especially where one proposal contains fees/charges
excluded from the other proposals, try to negotiate these
fees/charges.
9. Offer Credit Enhancement to Reduce Lease Rates
In some cases, you can trim lease pricing substantially by
offering credit enhancements to improve your firm’s credit
profile. Enhancements can include: shortening the lease term,
cash or other assets as additional collateral, personal or
corporate guarantees, advance rentals payments, and security
deposits. Since most credit enhancements involve giving up
something of value, do a cost/benefit analysis to determine
whether the net benefit is in your favor. If your firm has
assets that are not working for it why not put them to work in
the leasing arrangement. The value of credit enhancements can
differ from lessor to lessor, so identify and discuss possible
enhancements upfront. Try to assess whether your firm’s credit
will improve significantly by credit enhancements and get
lessors’ pricing with and without the credit enhancements.
10. Request Several End-of-lease Options
If the lease contains a nominal purchase option, there is little
need for additional end-of-lease flexibility. Otherwise,
flexible end-of-lease options can save you a bundle by
preventing you from incurring extra expense. One of the most
cost-effective options is the ability to return the equipment at
the end of the lease. If you no longer need the equipment, why
incur additional charges? Additionally you should have the
ability to purchase the equipment at a fair or reduced price and
the right to continue leasing the equipment at a fair or reduced
rent. As discussed, use of caps in fair market value purchase or
rental options can greatly reduce potential costs at lease end.
Conclusion
Saving a bundle on your next lease is a cinch if you know where
to look. By focusing on a few key areas, you can wring huge
savings out of your lease. Remember to set your priorities in
evaluating lease proposals and to choose the right leasing
partner. Also, while front-end lease pricing is usually a high
priority, evaluate each lease carefully to sniff out hidden fees
and expenses. Don’t be bashful about negotiating points in the
lease that have the potential to save you a bundle.
About Author :
George Parker is a Director and Executive Vice President of
Leasing Technologies International, Inc. (“LTI”). Headquartered
in Wilton, CT, LTI is a leasing firm specializing nationally in
equipment financing programs for emerging growth and
later-stage, venture capital backed companies. More information
about LTI is available at: www.ltileasing.com.