|
08 Mar 2008 12:27:47 | John Marchionne
It amazes me that the over use of the tab system for playing
guitar has never before, that I know of anyway, been equated
to painting by numbers. While it's fine for the amateur player
and garage band hack, it has increasingly been brought into
the real world of music. Some of you may remember all those
tad polls and squiggly lines, clefs, staffs and bars, Italian
words like legato, staccato and all those other ato's. They
were fine for us and with the right teacher, (which is
increasingly hard to find, but that's another article), they
were even fun. It seems to me that this wonderful teaching
tool called tablature has been abused in this immediate
satisfaction world that now seems to exist. Not to mention
the spitting in the face of Segovia, Chet Atkins, Wes
Montgomery, Joe Pass, Tal Farlow, B.B. King, Eric Clapton,
have I made my point yet. Tab hackers cannot be compared
with us, the true musicians.
It is the responsibility of us as teachers to not give in to
the pressures of easy play guitar or any instrument for that
matter. The guitar and piano have become the most abused of
these systems due to the numerical and patterned designs of
the instrument. True professionals should be insulted by the
rash of infection within our craft of ineptly trained players
who in times of old would have been confined to play only at
family gatherings and high school summer bashes of drunken
teenagers who copped some beer and weed. It's not to say that
it's not nice for them to play that way. I'll even give them
an occasional an "how cute." Heck, I've been told by well-
meaning but misinformed parents to "just let them play and
have fun, they don't need to learn theory". Personally I
think it's fine that some learn and play this way, as long
as you confine it to old aunt Bessie and grandma or even some
bucket of blood in the Keys, but kindly do not include yourself
as one of us. You are not. If you can't read music, know little
to nothing about theory, then you are not a musician.
I'm not trying to be harsh here, I'm only trying to protect
the craft I've struggled to perfect, both playing and especially
teaching. I've found that the ones that don't care or are just
lazy simply will not learn any faster, with or without the tabs.
The real tragedies are the ones who do care or come to care
later on and then it's even harder to learn theory. You go from
this easy paint by numbers format and learning cool songs like
Sweet Home Alabama, Smoke on the Water to Twinkle, Twinkle
Little Star. Yea, that'll work. Guess what? You've just ruined
what could have become a fine musician, amateur or not, and
wasted all the money in lessons up to that point. Not to mention
the cost of the dust-gathering instrument which, by the way,
does not make a good clothes line like exercise machines. Most
importantly, you've given another blow to the true craftsmen,
the musician.
Kindly do not succumb to this practice, hire a real professional
with a lot of great references and pay him the extra bucks, it's
worth it.
About Author :
|