20 Feb 2008 05:36:56 | Susan J. Schutz
I had to laugh when a friend told me recently that he’d never
had trouble finding his shout, but the concept of finding his
voice was really new to him. When my laughter subsided I was
able to assure him that he’s by far not alone! Dynamic tension
is a marvelous and necessary source of creative energy in the
workplace, yet it amazes me that more businesses don’t implode.
Often the tension present is more destructive than it is
generative. From the point of contact with customers to
executive offices and everywhere in between I’ve watched at
Highest Vision as people launch their words like torpedoes
designed to obliterate a monstrous enemy or, on the contrary,
stuff overwhelming frustrations or brilliant ideas until they
all but explode from them. Often the higher the stakes, the more
dysfunctional the communication!
The first impulse for many who use the bulldozer approach is to
say that they don’t care how they sound or how their message is
received. They’re convinced that they’ve earned the right, that
it’s the only way to get something done, or that the recipient
of their wrath deserves everything they’ve sent their way—and
then some! On the other hand, many of those who are unwilling to
put their voices out there have developed a “learned
helplessness” (no one listens anyway), hold a belief that they
don’t have the intelligence, right or authority to offer their
perspective, or they’ve experienced repercussions and will no
longer risk having their thoughts and feelings used against
them. Rather than being overbearing, these individuals have
voices that are offered as mere squeaks, are targeted at the
wrong people, or are used long after they could be of value.
Unfortunately the costs associated with these two communication
extremes are more than individuals or the organizations that
employ them can responsibly overlook. Finding our voices,
whether that means having to draw back to find them or having to
excavate them from the very depths of our souls, is about
reclaiming the vitality that fuels meaningful successes.
The sad irony of poor communication is that when people are
removed from the person or situation that has evoked their
specific reaction they can describe in detail what effect their
yelling, demanding, or stifled voices will have on the outcome
of the exchange. They know that one “side" will either angrily
and resentfully capitulate while then seeking to undermine the
other, or the two will get locked into a power battle in which,
ultimately, everyone loses. The obvious losses include:
alienated customers, unspoken resentments that leave colleagues
working against rather than with each other, and a diminished
bottom line.
Specifically these things translate into lost time, energy,
money, and productivity, as well as the agility to respond
quickly to changes in one’s industry or the economy. Increased
stress, compromised health and outcomes that are far less than
what is possible can send the people involved scurrying to find
a more amenable work environment.
If people know the results aren’t going to serve them well
either in the short or long-term, why do so many insist on
staying stuck in ineffective communication patterns? After all,
as is so often quoted, the definition of insanity is to repeat
the same behaviors over and over expecting different results.
Unfortunately, many simply aren’t conscious of their own
pattern, believe that it is caused by others or the environment,
and/or don’t know what to do instead. For some they’ve simply
become accustomed to “power battles” and believe that when there
are issues that people feel passionately about these dynamics
are unavoidable.
How can you speak out without alienating others?
****Check your intent and be thoughtful of your delivery**** Is
your goal to respectfully communicate? Address the issue or
behavior without making it a personal attack. Use the person’s
name (when appropriate) and a compassionately assertive tone of
voice—even when your voice must also convey an intensity of
feeling or conviction. Avoid labels, name-calling or use of
“trigger words.” (“You arrogant, self-centered, manipulative
jerk” has never been the kind of phrase that invites thoughtful
discussion!)
****Take up your share of space—no more, no less.****
Conceptually, two people can only take up a finite amount of
space. If you take up too much of that space it invites others
to battle you for their fair share or to resentfully cower in
the small corner you’ve left to them. On the other hand, because
nature abhors a vacuum, if you take up too little space, it
invites others to expand and overpower you. Hold your head up,
offer good eye contact, but keep your muscles relaxed. Slamming
your truth into someone’s face invites them to instinctually
recoil and/or come out fighting; never putting your needs out
there for someone else to consider almost guarantees that you’ll
be overlooked, stepped on, or pushed aside. Be willing to
contribute whatever it is you have to offer.
**** Recognize that there can be many different “truths.”**** In
most cases your perspective is neither right nor wrong, it is
simply what your particular vantage point allows you to offer.
Rather than working with the assumption that you have nothing to
offer, or that you hold the only perspective of value, trust
that each person may be the only one who can offer their
particular “truth.” If you leave your perspective unsaid, or
drown out someone else’s voice, you will have short-circuited
the process that creates understanding, buy-in, and higher
levels of creative thinking. When it is necessary to
supportively confront someone you can use “I” messages to take
responsibility for your own thoughts, feelings, and actions. (A
frequently used formula for “I” messages includes the following
four parts: 1) I think / feel…2) when you…3) because…4) I want /
need…). Avoid drawing unnecessary lines in the sand, or “making
someone wrong” just because you have different perspectives.
****Take your words directly to the person who needs to hear
them.**** Don’t count on people to read your mind or assume that
they “should” already understand your perspective. Regardless of
whether you’re frustrated with investors, your boss, colleagues,
staff, customers, or someone on the home front, grumbling with
people who aren’t in a position to effect change will only leave
you feeling more powerless and/or resentful. Rather than blaming
them for your unwillingness to express yourself, find a way to
language and deliver your message in a timely and effective
fashion to the person or people who need to hear it. Use a third
party as a sounding board if intense emotions or previous
attempts at communication have you wanting to skip the issue
altogether. (Ensure that your goal in talking with this neutral
party is to bolster your ability for communicating directly and
not simply to gain an ally!)
****Remember that “telling your truth” also involves
listening.**** Nothing makes it easier for someone to hear what
we have to offer than our own willingness to really listen—and
sometimes doing so first allows the other person to clear out
their own systems and have space to consider what we most want
them to hear. More than just keeping your mouth shut and
impatiently tapping your foot, genuine listening involves making
a real effort to understand the other’s perspective. Ask
clarifying questions or paraphrase to communicate back to the
speaker your understanding of what’s been said.
****Use levity, humor, sincere praise and acknowledgment when
appropriate.**** When we let things stay unnecessarily serious,
intense, or oppositional people grow tense and impatient. Be the
bearer of light in your organization—be willing to deal
honestly, openly, and directly with the issues that need to be
discussed, yet take the opportunity to appreciate life and each
other at every opportunity!
for a free subscription to Vantage Point, an E-zine for
trailblazers in lfe and business, go to www.highest-vision.com.
About Author :
Susan J. Schutz founded Highest Vision in 1999 as a reflection
of her deep conviction that professionals can be attentive to
their “bottom lines” while also creating lives worth living and
businesses that contribute to the good of all.